Is there a way to run constrained VAR in EViews?
For example, I wish to run a model with 4 variables, say x, y , z and w. But I don't want w to depend on itself only on the other variables...
Or, as another example, I don't want x to depend on z but on the rest.
Is this handled through SVAR? Does this problem have a name? Like constrained VAR or something similar?
Thanks!
Constrained VAR in EViews?
Moderators: EViews Gareth, EViews Moderator
-
Seeking_Knowledge
- Posts: 20
- Joined: Sat Mar 22, 2014 1:42 pm
Re: Constrained VAR in EViews?
Hello
An important part of VAR analysis is to let the 'data decide what is x and y '
Quick ---> Estimate VAR ------> Endogenous variable..... and put x or w in exognous after C
in that way at least you have defined some variables as predictors...
Ln [ w ] = c β1x β2y β2z
Ln [ x ] = c β1x β2y
not sure if I understood your problem..... but good luck
An important part of VAR analysis is to let the 'data decide what is x and y '
Quick ---> Estimate VAR ------> Endogenous variable..... and put x or w in exognous after C
in that way at least you have defined some variables as predictors...
Ln [ w ] = c β1x β2y β2z
Ln [ x ] = c β1x β2y
not sure if I understood your problem..... but good luck
Last edited by Seeking_Knowledge on Mon May 12, 2014 4:01 pm, edited 1 time in total.
-
EViews Glenn
- EViews Developer
- Posts: 2682
- Joined: Wed Oct 15, 2008 9:17 am
Re: Constrained VAR in EViews?
Thanks for the prompt reply!
Let me explain some more:
Let's say that I have x, y and z. Let's assume that x is salary and y and z are work output. I know that at every time t, x(t) is simply a*y(t-1)+b*z(t-1), in other words, the employer rewards the employee according to her output. So, I know for a fact that x(t) does not depend on x(t-1) and so I would like to exclude it. What I am afraid could happen (if I do include x(t-1) in x(t)'s equation) is that it will be co-linear and will "absorb" the variance so that I will not see the dependence of x(t) on z(t-1) and y(t-1) and so cannot estimate a and b.
This is exactly what I see in the data, i.e., even though I know x(t)=a*y(t-1)+b*z(t-1) is the right equation, a and b only sometimes are significant and I am afraid it is because I include x(t-1) in the estimation.
Does this make any sense?
P.S.
Making an equation system seems like a nice solution, but losing the IRFs is critical. Do you think there's a way to recreate IRFs if I use the eqtn system?
Let me explain some more:
Let's say that I have x, y and z. Let's assume that x is salary and y and z are work output. I know that at every time t, x(t) is simply a*y(t-1)+b*z(t-1), in other words, the employer rewards the employee according to her output. So, I know for a fact that x(t) does not depend on x(t-1) and so I would like to exclude it. What I am afraid could happen (if I do include x(t-1) in x(t)'s equation) is that it will be co-linear and will "absorb" the variance so that I will not see the dependence of x(t) on z(t-1) and y(t-1) and so cannot estimate a and b.
This is exactly what I see in the data, i.e., even though I know x(t)=a*y(t-1)+b*z(t-1) is the right equation, a and b only sometimes are significant and I am afraid it is because I include x(t-1) in the estimation.
Does this make any sense?
P.S.
Making an equation system seems like a nice solution, but losing the IRFs is critical. Do you think there's a way to recreate IRFs if I use the eqtn system?
Re: Constrained VAR in EViews?
Just to stress the point - I KNOW that x(t) does not depend explicitly on x(t-1): assume that a computer calculates x(t) according to the formula I gave above (which is actually the case for my data - x(t) for the data is calculated by an automatic algorithm...)
-
EViews Glenn
- EViews Developer
- Posts: 2682
- Joined: Wed Oct 15, 2008 9:17 am
Re: Constrained VAR in EViews?
What you are asking for is reasonable, though not typical of VAR analysis. Having said that, unfortunately, when estimating as a system you will lose the IRF functionality. You'd have to do the calculations yourself.
Re: Constrained VAR in EViews?
I understand, thanks!
Re: Constrained VAR in EViews?
Does anyone know if I can do this in the context of an SVAR model? (i.e., create some sort of restrictions that will produce such a model...)
Return to “Econometric Discussions”
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests
